This journal is published in collaboration with the Scientific Association of Industrial Management of Iran.

-------------------------------------------------- --------

The Journal of Management Research in Iran is one of the publications of Tarbiat Modares University, which is published under the scientific responsibility of the editor and the editorial board.
The Journal of Humanities in various fields of humanities has been published as a war since the fall of 1990. In 1375, he succeeded in obtaining a scientific-research degree, and since the spring of 1380, according to the policy of the Ministry of Science; Based on the specialization of journals, it was published in three fields of law, management and geography, which continued until October 2009. From October 2009 based on the new policy of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology to specialize journals; Modares Journal of Humanities (Management) was given permission to publish the journal with a new specialized title; According to which the journal of the teacher of humanities for management, will be published from now on with the title of "Scientific-research quarterly of teacher of humanities-management research in Iran". The scientific research journal "Management Research in Iran" is published by the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance with a publication license number: 48320 on: 14/6/91.

 

Plagiarism: The Quarterly uses Samim Noor's similarity detection system to ensure ownership and non-similarity to other articles to ensure the authenticity of the work.
Judgment and acceptance process of the article: Click here to view the acceptance process of the article in the form of a chart.
Download magazine format: Click here to download magazine format in word file format.
Access type: Free and open access to articles (open access)
Type of arbitration: closed arbitration (two sides unknown) and 2 arbitrators
Cost of reviewing and accepting articles: Free
Types of articles that can be published in the journal: Research, Review
Initial review period of received articles: 7 to 10 days
Average time interval of the article acceptance refereeing process: up to 6 months

-------------------------------------------------- --------

This Journal is an open access Journal Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

This publication is subject to the rules of the ethics committee in copying and follows the executive regulations of the Law on Prevention and Combating Fraud in Scientific Works.

Original Article

A Novel Network DEA Model Based on the Directional Distance Function for Simultaneous Handling of Negative and Integer-valued Data

Pages 1-32

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.28272

Hossein Azizi, Somayyeh Rashid

Abstract Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), as a non-parametric and data-driven methodology, is an effective tool for assessing the relative efficiency of a set of decision-making units (DMUs) with multiple inputs and outputs. However, classical DEA models disregard the internal structure of DMUs and treat them as “black boxes.” To overcome this limitation, network DEA has been developed to explicitly model the internal interactions among the components of each DMU. Moreover, in many real-world applications, certain input, output, or intermediate variables are inherently discrete and take integer values, and negative data may also be present. Such characteristics are typically ignored in conventional DEA models and can lead to inaccurate or impractical efficiency estimates. This paper proposes a novel network DEA model based on the directional distance function for two-division series systems, capable of simultaneously handling negative data and integer-valued variables. By defining an appropriate direction vector, the proposed model enables the measurement of system efficiency under both constant returns to scale and variable returns to scale. To demonstrate the capabilities of the proposed model, a real case study involving 29 Iranian supply chains in the medical consumables industry is conducted. The results show that the proposed model not only accurately distinguishes between efficient and inefficient DMUs but also provides projection points that specify the exact pathway for performance improvement in each division. The findings indicate that the proposed approach can serve as a robust and reliable tool for evaluating and enhancing supply chain efficiency, particularly in sensitive industries such as medical consumables.

Original Article

Clarifying the Concept of "Strategizing" in Strategic Management: A Concept Analysis Approach

Pages 34-58

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.28106

Ali Heidari, Ayoob Mohammadian, Mohammad Ali Shah Hosseini, Mehdi Abdi

Abstract The concept of strategizing, as a contemporary and applied notion in strategic management, is characterized by conceptual ambiguity and limited exploration in terms of its definition and dimensions. This study aims to clarify the concept of strategizing and reduce existing ambiguities in the literature by employing Suddaby’s conceptual analysis framework. To this end, research articles published between 1990 and July 21, 2025, were retrieved and analyzed from the Scopus database using the keywords “strategizing” and “strategy-as-practice”. The findings include: a clear definition of strategizing, specification of its analytical levels, temporal scope, and value foundations, comparison with related concepts, and the provision of a coherent framework for the concept. The proposed conceptual framework facilitates the effective application of the strategizing concept at the business, corporate, and ecosystem levels. This research contributes to the conceptual development of strategizing and serves as a foundation for future studies, particularly those exploring the required capabilities for strategizing and the mechanisms for its implementation across different organizational and managerial levels.

Original Article

Providing a model for developing corporate innovative capabilities with a blue ocean approach in pharmaceutical companies

Pages 60-92

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.28104

jihad Salim Abbas, mohammad bashokouh, Gassem Zarei, Naser Seyfollhi

Abstract This study aims to explore and analyze the components and categories of enhancing innovation capacity through the application of the blue ocean strategy in the Iraqi pharmaceutical industry. Conducted as an applied research project, it employs a qualitative approach using thematic analysis. Data were gathered through semi-structured interviews with 19 managers and experts in marketing and the pharmaceutical sector, analyzed across three coding phases: open, axial, and selective. During the open coding phase, 77 initial codes were identified and grouped into 12 axial categories: red ocean challenges, the necessity to move beyond traditional competition, advantages of the blue ocean strategy, elimination of unnecessary factors, reduction of low-value factors, enhancement of existing factors, creation of new factors, expansion of innovation capacity, integration of emerging technologies, sustainability and long-term impacts, and strategic foresight. These categories were subsequently consolidated into four overarching themes: challenges, tools, applications, and outcomes. The findings reveal that competitive challenges characteristic of red ocean environments, such as intense traditional rivalry and innovation limitations, can be effectively addressed through the four-pronged framework of elimination, reduction, enhancement, and creation. By fostering new markets and incorporating advanced technologies, the blue ocean strategy enhances innovation capacity and economic sustainability, promotes transformative innovation, and establishes a enduring competitive edge.

Original Article

Identifying the factors Iranian online customers expect from interacting with chatbots

Pages 94-127

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.28270

shahriar azizi, Hesamedin Nemati, Navid Khanjanzadeh

Abstract Chatbots, as one of the important applications of artificial intelligence, are increasingly used in interactions between customers and organizations and play an important role in improving customer experience. Despite the widespread use of this technology, systematic understanding of users' expectations of chatbots, especially in the Iranian cultural context, remains limited. The aim of the present study is to identify and explain Iranian customers' expectations of interacting with chatbots in online environments. This study was conducted with a qualitative approach and using the theme analysis method. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 20 users with practical experience or familiarity with chatbots, and sampling was continued using the snowball method until theoretical saturation was achieved. In the data analysis process, 109 basic themes were extracted and classified into 23 organizing themes and 6 overarching themes. The findings show that customers' expectations of chatbots can be explained in six main dimensions, including effectiveness, quality of response, humanness, communication, security, and accessibility. These dimensions encompass a range of functional, interactive, and emotional expectations of users and indicate that customers, in addition to the speed and accuracy of responses, also pay special attention to features such as empathy, understanding the context of the conversation, personalization of interaction, and privacy. The results of this research can provide a practical basis for the design, development, and improvement of service chatbots tailored to the needs and characteristics of Iranian users.

Original Article

Intelligent Predictive Model of Purchase Intention and Behavior in the Refurbished Electronics Market Using Neural Networks: Evidence from Iran

Pages 129-157

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.28271

marzieh soltani, Ameneh Khadivar

Abstract Refurbished electronics such as smartphones and laptops are increasingly positioned as sustainable and affordable options amid rising e-waste and resource constraints, yet consumer acceptance in Iran remains insufficiently understood. This study integrates Ajzen’s Theory of Planned Behavior and Schwartz’s Norm Activation framework to propose a prediction-oriented model based on artificial neural networks (ANN) for estimating purchase intention and behavior and for quantifying the relative contribution of theoretical constructs. The research is descriptive–applied, survey-based, and cross-sectional; data were collected from 400 Iranian consumers of smartphones and laptops in Fall–Winter 2024 using convenience sampling and a five-point questionnaire. After data cleaning, reverse-coding of negatively worded items, and min–max normalization, multilayer ANNs were trained in MATLAB with a 70/15/15 split for training/validation/testing. Beyond prediction, variable importance was derived via sensitivity analysis. Results indicate that the ANN provides reliable out-of-sample prediction for both intention and behavior. In the ranking of drivers, perceived behavioral control and attitude toward the behavior contribute most to explaining purchase behavior, while purchase intention remains an effective bridge from cognitive constructs to actual behavior. Subjective norms, personal norms (morality), and awareness of consequences exert positive but more modest effects. The learning-based approach offers a finer-grained picture of latent patterns than linear explanations and yields a more dependable estimate of purchase likelihood in the Iranian context. Managerially, effective policies should jointly strengthen perceived capability and ease of action (e.g., simpler purchase processes and lower after-sales risk) and build favorable attitudes grounded in economic and environmental benefits to increase acceptance of

Review Article

A Meta-Analytic of Options Market Efficiency: Model-Based Tests Approach

Pages 159-188

https://doi.org/10.48311/mri.2026.27636

Saeed Fathi, Nahid Fattahalmannan

Abstract Two primary approaches exist for empirical tests assessing the efficiency of options contract markets: the model-based approach and the arbitrage-based approach. Numerous empirical studies have examined model-based efficiency (comparing model-derived option prices with market prices). Still, they have yielded conflicting results regarding the efficiency of the options market, with some studies supporting market efficiency and others rejecting it. This study conducts a meta-analysis of options market efficiency under the model-based approach to reconcile these contradictions and identify their underlying causes. We selected 30 studies published between 2003 and 2022 in SCOPUS-indexed journals, extracting 6,409 test samples for hypothesis testing. The sample includes all reported tests in prior empirical studies (published in SCOPUS-indexed journals) on model-based options market efficiency. Our findings reject market efficiency, indicating a significant divergence between option contract prices and their intrinsic values. Robustness tests—including efficiency metrics, option pricing models, journal H index, analysis date, and moneyness depth—consistently confirm this conclusion.

Original Article

Identifying Dimensions and Assessment Models of Professional Qualifications in Digital Marketing Jobs

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 12 January 2026

soroorolsadat sayyah, jalil younesi, noorali farrokhi, gholamreza yadegarzadeh

Abstract The aim of this study was to identify the dimensions and assessment models of professional qualifications in digital marketing jobs. This research employed a systematic review method, focusing on studies published in international databases between 2016 and 2025. Ultimately, eight selected articles were approved, analyzed, and synthesized. findings revealed that assessing soft skills—such as analytical thinking and problem-solving, communication skills, teamwork, management skills, personal attributes, and interpersonal abilities—plays a significant role in evaluating the professional qualifications of individuals in digital marketing roles. another key finding was that integrated models like DigComp are recognized as some of the most comprehensive frameworks for assessment in this field. In addition to general qualifications, DigComp covers five core areas: information and data literacy, communication, content creation, safety, and problem-solving. Furthermore, the 21st Century Skills Model, which includes learning skills, digital literacies, and life and career skills, along with performance-based situational questionnaires and assessments, can serve as effective, multidimensional tools for evaluating individuals’ qualifications in these occupations.

Original Article

Designing a talent development model in the Iran Supreme Audit Court

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 12 January 2026

Rouhollah Al-Reza Nematollahi, Reza Tahmasebi, Seyyed Mahdi Alvani, Hasan Zarei Matin

Abstract Development of key personnel, as one of the basic components of human resource management, plays a pivotal role in improving the efficiency, effectiveness, and learning of organizations. The aim of the present study is to design a talent development model in the Court of Accounts of the country. This study was conducted with an interpretive paradigm, a qualitative approach, a case study strategy, and a content analysis method. The research population included organizational experts in key positions who were identified and clustered based on the experts' opinions. To collect data, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 19 experts selected through purposive sampling, and the data were analyzed until theoretical saturation was reached. The findings showed that the talent development model in the Court of Accounts consists of four main parts: (1) goals and strategies, (2) what and areas of development, (3) how and mechanisms of development, and (4) individual and organizational results. The studies showed that key forces have been developed in some areas, such as personal and technical competencies, but for the future they also need to pay attention to other areas. Also, the experts emphasized the difference in mechanisms, level and implementation between key forces and other employees. The identified talent development mechanisms fall into four main categories: job-based, relationship-based, formal program-based and informal/informal mechanisms. This model can be used as a practical basis for designing and improving talent management programs in the Court of Accounts and similar organizations.

Original Article

Analysis of government intervention in the development process

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 11 November 2025

Saeed Zarandi, mohammad kazempour teymourloy

Abstract The developments of the last few decades in the economy, even capitalism and the crisis of 2007, show that it is impossible to talk about the withdrawal of the government in the development process. The level of government involvement in the development process is one of the important issues of the economy. The main goal of this research is to describe the way and scope of government intervention. The research method of this research is descriptive-analytical. Government production of goods and services, transfer payments, taxes and regulations are the four main channels of the government to influence economic activities. And the regulation of the government's optimal intervention based on investment, commercial and industrial policy has been investigated. Based on the results of the research, contrary to liberal beliefs that government intervention hinders development in East Asian countries, the conscious intervention of government agents is the main factor in the development of these countries, and the main focus in these countries is on the manner and scope of government intervention instead of interference or non-interference. In our country, the presence of the government should be comprehensive and focused on development. With the intervention of the government in the processes of development, regulation and guidance of the market mechanism, inadequacies can be eliminated and the economic system can be driven to a better situation in terms of resource allocation and economic capacity creation.

The evolution of human resource management knowledge in Iran

Volume 24, Issue 4, Autumn 2020, Pages 156-175

Mohammad Shahab Sheybani Far, Abbas Ali Rastegar, Seyyed Mahdi Alvani, Hosein Damghanian, Hasan Danai Fard Danai Fard

Abstract Adopting a scientific approach to management and human resource management in Iran is less than a century old. This study has studied the evolution of "human resource management knowledge" in Iran using the qualitative research strategy of the Grounded Theory. The research data were obtained from interviews with a group of veteran professors of Iranian management knowledge, supplemented with data collected from written sources. The oral and written data of the research were then analyzed using open coding, central coding, and selective coding. The final theory based on the systematic model of the Strauss and Corbinchr('39')s Grounded theory categorizes the evolution of human resource management knowledge in Iran into four historical periods: "period of formation", "period of growth", "period of separation" and "period of re-creation" of human resources.

Identification and Explanation the Factors Affecting The Sustainability of Strategic Alliances With Systematic Review Approach

Volume 27, Issue 1, Winter 2023, Pages 144-173

salman eivazinezhad, bahman hajipour, Nabi Allah dehghan

Abstract Alliances can be a very effective way to achieve new strategic opportunities, but despite this, a high percentage of strategic alliances fail and end failure.. Therefore, the present study sought to identify the factors affecting the stability and stability of strategic alliances using a systematic review. The case of the study was all articles accepted from invalid databases after filtering in several stages, 44 articles were reviewed for final evaluation and analysis. In the coding process stage, the selected articles were performed and 30 sub-themes were divided into three main themes: Senior management team, structure, and business. In the individual section, the strategic ability of the leaders, the commitment of the senior management team, the coordination between the senior managers of the units, having interdisciplinary specializations, and having previous experience in the inter-company cooperation space were identified. In the structure section, module management process, continuous and short-term performance feedback, data output transparency, number of module partners, complementary resources, distinct goals, having an international perspective, intangible outputs, symmetric learning capabilities, clear division of labor, a form of governance, Type of contract, reward system, contract orientation and type of exchange were identified; For the business sector, cultural distance, market growth, partner reputation, partner size, partner experience, contract territory, type of partner activity, cash flow of each partner, a unique type of exchange, correct choice of key partner were selected. Finally, based on the five identified proportions (cultural, strategic, operational, organizational, and individual) at each level of sustainability, it can be significantly increased

Bank-fintech Collaboration: A Systematic Literature Review

Volume 23, Issue 4, Autumn 2019, Pages 130-172

reza payandeh, Meisam Shahbazi, Manouchehr Manteghi, toraj karimi

Abstract The global banking industry, driven by new technologies and changing customer behavior, has undergone major changes unprecedentedly all over its history. As banks contend with innovation challenges in their processes, fintech companies benefiting from digital capabilities, deliver innovative and customer-centric services. In the business world, the collaboration between these two institutions has taken many forms. This has also attracted the attention of the academic community, and several papers have been written in this field. The purpose of this article is to review these articles, and its main question is: What has the scientific literature contribute toward bank-fintech collaboration? To answer this question, a systematic literature review, based on PRISMA Checklist, has been utilized and various specific areas have been examined to understand the necessity, evolution, challenges, drivers, benefits, barriers, and types of bank-fintech collaboration in the scientific articles. The most significant achievements of the articles are discussed in the paper; furthermore, different types of bank-fintech collaboration in the scientific literature are listed, and a bank-fintech collaboration algorithm is presented. Ultimately, the gaps in the literature and suggestions for future research are expressed.

To assess digital supply chain in manufacturing industries (Case study: Bedding industry)

Volume 26, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 139-163

pezhvak mehdipour, AbdolHamid Safaei Ghadikolaee, Hamidreza Fallah Lajimi, hassanali aghajani

Abstract One of the main challenges constantly facing the majority of the organizations is planning to develop and improve processes and operations based on the adoption of new technologies, especially digital technologies, to react to the requirements of markets and competitive environments. Therefore, by using hybrid research approach (qualitative and quantitative), the present study explores the applications of digital technologies in terms of technical needs and business performances in the supply chain network of the bedding industry. The method includes developing an efficient measurement tool to evaluate the digitalization and automation specifications for integrated management of the supply chain operations and flows in manufacturing industries and validating it using the multi-criteria decision-making approach DANP (DEMATEL-based ANP), which is considered the study’s contribution to knowledge and the literature. Therefore, in the first step, the list of influential factors was determined as 6 process areas and a total of 22 related attributes using the desk-based research and Delphi method. Then, the weights and relationships among factors were evaluated using the DANP technique. According to the obtained results, the process area of inventory and warehouse management is considered the most critical factor with the highest weight. However, the process areas of sourcing and buy and business management were identified as the most effective factors in improving critical areas.

Presenting a Conceptual framework of Customer Relationship Management in Electronic Banking with Emphasis on Using Business Intelligence Tools (Case Study: Sepah Bank and Merged Banks)

Volume 26, Issue 1, Spring 2022, Pages 246-271

sayed mohammad reza vakil, kaveh teymoor nejad, mohammad reza motadel, mahmood moammadi

Abstract Customer relationship management provides the basis for customer optimal communication, customer loyalty and customer retention. This requires the design of customer-based strategies, the proper implementation and applying of technology, employee empowerment and increasing the level of customers knowledge. Given the advances in e-banking and the reduction of face-to-face contact points, the use of business intelligence tools to effectively use large volumes of customer information also seems necessary. The purpose of present study is to provide a conceptual framework for customer relationship management in electronic banking using business intelligence tools in Sepah Bank and merged banks. For this purpose, a qualitative research has been conducted and first, by reviewing the studies, the initial framework has been identified and then, Theme Analysis has been used for its development in electronic banking. The research population is 7 experts of case study. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect data and credibility and confirmability were used to assess the validity of the results. After analyzing the data, the customer relationship management framework in e-banking is classified into 6 dimensions, 16 components and 35 indicators. The main dimensions of which are Customer reach and acquisition, Customer identification, Customer attraction, Customer relationship development, Customer retention and customer relationship review.

The Dynamics of Accounting Information in Stock Valuation: An Industry-Based Analysis

Volume 21, Issue 1, Spring 2017, Pages 29-63

Mohammad Amri-Asrami, Mohammad-Ali Aghaei

Abstract Industrial groups have interactions within and outside groups. In this paper, twelve industrial groups of companies listed in Tehran Stock Exchange are reviewed in order to evaluate linear information dynamics. Conservatism measures of “ratio of sum of price to sum of book value” and “mean of price-to-book ratio” are considered. In sample periods, in order to remedy the effects of special factors in sample industries, later ratio is de-trended. For controlling effects of each industry, inflation, and some other factors on the various industry indices, two measures of “average annual difference between price and book value” and “each industry index” are considered. Industry analysis shows that "sum of price to sum of book value" criterion has a significant correlation with the average of market value to book value and the correlation would be stronger if using the de-trended criteriun. Finally, comparing scaled variables on the average annual difference between price and book value, it concluded that scaled variables based on the index of each industry led to a much stronger coefficient of valuation models. Therefore, for assessment and analysis of linear information dynamics in industrial groups (including environmental factors such as conservatism in accounting policies, industry, stock market indices, cost of capital rate, inflation, the policy of dividend distribution, past and present of book value and securities) can be used for developing residual income valuation models.

Relationship between Knowledge Sharing and Innovation in Financial Service Organizations (Case Study: Refah Kargaran Bank)

Volume 17, Issue 1, Winter 2013, Pages 201-220

parvin mohebi, akram hadizadeh moghadam, behroz ghlichlee

Abstract   Knowledge sharing creates opportunities to maximize the organization’s ability to meet those needs and generates solutions and efficiencies that provide a business with a competitive advantage. Knowledge sharing can be defined as a social interaction culture, involving the exchange of employees knowledge, experiences and skills through the whole department or organization. The concept of innovation has been closely related to “knowledge creation and knowledge sharing”. Innovation is a process where the knowledge is acquired, shared and assimilated with the aim of creating new knowledge, which embodies products and services. Through exchange tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge with others, the capacity of people increases to be involved in new situation and solve new problems. It further helps to build new solution for the next issues. So different kinds of knowledge sharing are necessary to create new knowledge and innovation. A descriptive–correlation survey approach was used in this study, and the questionnaires were filled in by the staff (n=96) in Refahe Kargaran Bank. In the 95% confidence level, the results of the study revealed that there is a positive. relationship between knowledge sharing and innovation. Also it was found that there is similar relationship between serial transfer and innovation. In addition, the same result were observed for near transfer, far transfer, strategic transfer and expert transfer with innovation. Finally, the research limitations and suggestions for further researches are presented.   Keywords:

Keywords Cloud

Related Journals