One of the new approaches to development is the good governance model, which can be achieved through e-governance. Given the extensive literature and the lack of a comprehensive and indigenous model for good e-government in the country, the present study aims to design a model for the establishment and development of good e-governance based on systematic review of articles and their analysis using a Meta-synthesis method. For this purpose, after searching the databases in the period of 2000 to 2018, finally 85 articles were selected and by analyzing their content, the relevant dimensions and codes were extracted and the importance and priority of each was determined using Shannon entropy. Based on research findings, Information and communication technology codes, Human resources with knowledge and skills in the use of information and communication technology, Confidentiality of information, network security, credibility and reliability of information, the reality of security laws, the validity of the information provided, the entry of legal procedures and civil society oversight of e-government performance, ease and convenience of citizens in using services and access to government information and the reduction of government spending were the most important factors among the 19 dimensions of establishing and developing good e-governance. Finally, After the research steps, the model of establishing and developing good e-governance was presented in three stages of reviewing and identifying the requirements, establishment and development of good e-governance.


  1. [1] Zahiri, A. (2015). Ecological Ratio of Good Governance Pattern. Journal of political science, 17(66), pp. 87-111. [In Persian]. [2] Emam-Jomezade, S.J., Shahram-nia, A.M., Safarian-Gamekhani, R.A. (2016). Good governance model; co-operative society and efficient government in development management. Journal of Political Science, 12(36), pp. 7-40. [In Persian]. [3] Razmi, M.j., Sedighi, S., Rezayian, S. (2015). Requirements for good governance to achieve human development. Journal of Developmental and Planning Economics Research, 4(2), pp. 51-57. [In Persian]. [4] Moghadasi, A.R., Manian, A., Gholipour, R.A., Hassan-zade, A.R. (2016). Designing a Good Electronic Governance Model in Iran's E-Learning. Journal of Information and Technology Management, 8(3), pp. 591-620. [In Persian]. [5] Arayi, V., Ghasemi, A., Moeini-far, Y. (2017). Policy Recommendations Obstacles to Good Governance in Public Administration (Case Study: Minoodasht Governorate and Municipality). Journal of Strategic Studies in Public Policy, 7(25), pp. 113-133. [In Persian]. [6] Hajilou, S. (2017). Good governance and development, Journal of promising Iran, 107, pp. 78-80. [In Persian]. [7] Eshghi, M., Sarlak, M.A., Darvish, H., Mousavi, m. (2019). Designing and Explaining the Pattern of the Entrepreneurial Organization in the Banking Industry of Iran (Case Study: Refah Bank), Journal of Management Researches in Iran, 23(2), pp. 1-23. [In Persian]. [8] Sar-Abadi, A., Tabatabaeiyan, S.H.A., Mir-Moezi, S.H., Amiri, M. (2016). Improving the quality of policy in science and technology with the Iranian Islamic approach: a qualitative study, Modern researches in decision making, 1(1), pp.167-188. [In Persian]. [9] Madon, Sh. (2015). ICT4D and E-Governance. The International Encyclopedia of Digital Communication and Society, First Edition. [10] Salam, M.A. (2013). E-Governance for Good Governance through Public Service Delivery, Master's Thesis of Arts in Governance and Development, Institute of Governance Studies, BRAC University, Bangladesh. [11] Mimbi, L., Kyobe, M. (2017). Public Perceptions of the Role of IT in Resolving Governance Challenges in a Transition State: THe Case of Tanzania. The electronic Journal of information systems in developing countries, 78(1), pp. 1-25. [12] Coicaud, J.M. (2016). Administering and Governing with Technology: The Question of Information Communication Technology and E-Governance. Journal of Global Policy, 7(2), pp. 296-300. [13] Ilyas, M. (2016). E-Governance Practices and Models; Options for Pakistan. Institute for Strategic Studies, Research and Analysis (ISSRA), pp. 43-64. [14] Ghorbani-zade, V.A., Elyasi, F. (2016). The Impact of Cultural and Technical Factors on Electronic Governance. Journal of Organizational Culture Management, 14(2), pp. 521-540. [In Persian]. [15] Kolbedari, A., Sobhiye, M.H., Ebrahimi, S.N.A. (2018). Develop a theoretical model of governance that affects the performance of large-scale multi-organizational civil partnership projects. Journal of Management Researches in Iran, 22(4), pp. 73-101. [In Persian]. [16] Derakhshan, R., Najaf-Beigi, R., Danesh-fard, K.A., Pilevari, N. (2017). Pathology of Good Governance Components (Accountability, Justice and Justice) in Markazi Jihad Agricultural Organization. Journal of Ethical Research, 8(2), pp. 89-104. [In Persian]. [17] Kwaku Kyem, P. (2016). Mobile Phone Expantion and Opportunities for E-Governance in Sub-Saharan Africa. The electronic Journal of information systems in developing countries, 75(6), pp. 1-15. [18] Koivisto, I. (2014). Varieties of Good Governance: A Suggestion of Discursive Plurality. International Journal for the Semiotics of Law - Revue internationale de Sémiotique juridique, 27(4), pp. 587-611. [19] Maleki, M. (2016). Investigating the performance of the municipality in the framework of good and worthy urban governance (studied: Ilam city areas). Journal of Ilam culture, 17(52 & 53), pp. 62-81. [In Persian]. [20] Moghadasi, A.R., Manian, A. (2014). Electronic Governance; Replacement or Transformation. Journal of Information Technology, 10(4), pp. 65-72. [In Persian]. [21] Jahangir Alam, M. (2012). E-Governance in Bangladesh: Present Problems and Possible Suggestions for Future Development. International Journal of Applied Information Systems (IJAIS), 4(8), pp. 21-25. [22] Mahundu, F. (2016). E-Governance: A Socialogocal Case Study of the Central Admission System in Tanzania. The electronic Journal of information systems in developing countries, 76(1), pp. 1-11. [23] Dash, S., Pani, S.K. (2016). E-Governance Paradigm Using Cloud Infrastructure: Benefits and Challenges. International Conference on Computational Modeling and Security, Bengaluru, India, pp. 843-855. [24] Tang, C. (2013). Perumal, R.; The characteristics and values of e-governance and the role of e-democracy. International Journal of Humanities and Management Sciences, 1(1), pp. 142-145. [25] Saeed, M. (2012). E-governance service delivery-an assessment of community information center model in India. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business, 3(9), pp. 1344-1359. [26] Nobari. N., Rahimi, M. (2010). Good Urban Governance: An Undoubted Need, Tehran City Studies and Planning Center, Danesh Shahr, 11. [In Persian]. [27] Zwahr, T., Finger, M. (2010). Enhancing the e-Governance Model: Enterprise Architecture as a Potential Methodology to build a Holistic Framework. Competence Centre e-Governance, EPFL, Lausanne, 1015, Switzerland. [28] Rostam-zade, N., Afshari, K., Alam, Z., Ghorbani, S. (2019). Presenting a good e-governance model in the Ministry of Sports and Youth. Journal of Sports Management Studies, 11(56), pp. 43-62. [In Persian]. [29] Ghodousi, M., Mahmoudi, J. (2017). Electronicization Causes Tendency to Good Governance or Good Governance Causes Electronic Tendency: Current Trends and Future Predictions. Journal of Future management research, 28(110), pp. 105-113. [In Persian]. [30] Bala, M., Verma, D. (2018). Governance to Good Governance through e-Governance: A critical review of Concept, Model, Initiatives & Challenges in India. International Journal of Management, IT & Engineering, 8(10), pp. 244-269. [31] Ahmed, B. (2018). The Linkage between E-governance and Good Governance: An Analysis on Bangladesh Public Administration. Humanities and Social Sciences, 6(4), pp. 114-120. [32] Sapru, R.K., Sapru, Y. (2014). Good Governance through E- Governance with Special Reference to India. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 60(2), pp. 313-331. [33] Zhang, J. (2005). Good Governance through E-Governance? Journal of E-Government, 2(4), pp. 39-71. [34] Baniasad, R., Bagheri-Meibodi, M., Bladian, S.M. (2018). Systematic study of strategic management research in selected scientific-research journals selected in the country: Swimming research gaps and guidelines for future researches. Strategic Management Research, 24(71), pp. 31-63. [In Persian]. [35] Raeeyat-Pishe, S., Ahmadi-Kohanali, R., Abbas-nejad, T. (2016). Applying a superior quality approach to provide a comprehensive model of supply chain sustainability assessment. Modern researches in decision making, 1(1), pp. 139-165. [In Persian]. [36] Pour-Ezzat, A.A. (2015). An Introduction to Scientific Research Methodology (Development of the Research Resource and its Defense). Tehran: Meidanchi publication, [In Persian]. [37] Nazari, M., & Dastar, H. (2019). The determinants of the pricing of a supermarket: an over-the-top approach. Journal of Research in New Marketing Research, 8(1), pp. 1-20. [In Persian]. [38] Dehghani, M., Yaghoubi, N.M., Mougheli, A.R., & Vazife, Z. (2016). A three-layer pattern for Feasibility and establishment of knowledge management by Meta-Synthesis Method (Integrated approach). Journal of public Organization Management, 3(4), pp. 93-107. [In Persian]. [40] [33] Soltani, F., Shahin, A., Shayemi, A. (2018), Design of Talent Excellence Model Using Systematic Review and Qualitative Review Approach in Isfahan Gas Company, Journal of Human Resources Management in Oil Industry, 8(32), pp. 51-83. [In Persian].